The Trump administration has dropped its legal challenge over the Alaska Senate race.
Justice Department lawyers told the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in a Nov. 19 filing that the case has become moot. The move ends a legal fight that had cast a cloud over the Alaska Senate race.
Who won the Alaska Senate race?
AP called the race for Democrat Mary Peltola. As of Nov. 19 at 3:46am WAT, with an estimated 99% of votes counted, AP’s count showed Peltola with 144,486 votes, or 50.1%, and Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan with 131,965 votes, or 45.8%. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., listed as undeclared, had 4,765 votes, or 1.7%. These numbers may have changed since then.
Peltola, who previously served in the U.S. House, is the first Alaska Native elected to Congress. She is Yup’ik and served in the Alaska Legislature before going to Washington.
Why did the Trump administration sue?
The administration sued in October over the inclusion of a second candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan on the ballot alongside Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, a Republican. Alaska uses open primaries and ranked choice voting in general elections.
It argued that the second Sullivan’s candidacy was designed to confuse voters. The lawsuit asked a federal court to block certification of the Alaska Senate race if the senator lost and the votes for the other Sullivan would have given the senator the win had they been counted for him.
The court did not rule on whether his candidacy was improper.
Why was the lawsuit dismissed?
U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the suit on Nov. 1, two days before the election. She ruled that the Justice Department lacked standing to bring the case.
She also said the department had not offered a workable plan to separate ballots cast for the second Sullivan and investigate them while preserving voter secrecy. Protecting the secrecy of each voter’s ballot is a core principle of American elections.
Standing means a party must show it has a direct stake in a case to bring it to court.
Why did the Justice Department drop the appeal?
The administration appealed Gleason’s ruling but told the appeals court on Nov. 19 that the case has become moot, meaning there is no longer a live dispute for the court to decide. Cases can become moot when events overtake the dispute, such as the certification of results.
The filing, as described in reports, did not detail why the department considers the case moot.
The lawsuit’s request depended on the votes for the second Sullivan being enough to change the outcome of the Alaska Senate race.
What does this mean for the Alaska Senate race?
With the appeal dropped, the legal fight over the ballot appears to be over. It was not clear whether the department would pursue any other action.
The case raised questions about how election officials should handle candidates with similar names, an issue that has surfaced in other races over the years. Some states have rules that let candidates list middle names or other details to tell similar names apart.
Supporters of the lawsuit said voters deserved protection from confusion, while critics said the challenge threatened ballot secrecy and could undermine trust in election results.
The Alaska Senate race was one of several Senate contests that drew national attention in the midterms, which saw Democrats make major gains. For Mary Peltola, the end of the case clears the way for her to take office in January.
The dropped appeal brings a quiet end to one of the most unusual disputes of the Alaska Senate race.

