A federal appeals court has blocked the Department of Transportation from withholding $73 million from New York in a fight over commercial driver’s licenses issued to foreign drivers.
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Nov. 13 that the department lacked the legal authority to cut the money. The ruling is a setback for the Trump administration’s push to tighten licensing rules for foreign truck drivers.
Why did DOT withhold the money?
The department said New York failed to limit how long commercial driver’s licenses issued to drivers from other countries stayed valid.
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration determined that such licenses should expire on the same date as a driver’s documents showing legal presence in the United States. Drivers who are not citizens or permanent residents often hold temporary documents tied to visas or work permits.
A 2025 review by the agency found that roughly half of a sample of 200 such licenses and learner’s permits in New York remained valid even after the drivers’ legal status had expired.
In December 2025, the department told New York to immediately revoke every license it said had been illegally issued to foreign drivers or lose funding. New York challenged the move in court.
What did the court decide about commercial driver’s licenses?
The court sided with New York, finding that the federal regulation never actually required commercial driver’s licenses to expire with a driver’s legal presence documents.
Because the rule did not include that requirement, the department could not punish the state for failing to follow it, the majority opinion said. In other words, the agency tried to enforce a standard that was never written into its rules.
The ruling came in a majority opinion, suggesting at least one judge on the panel did not fully join it.
Why are these licenses under scrutiny?
The Trump administration has made commercial driver’s licenses for foreign drivers a priority after a deadly crash in Florida in August 2025 involving a truck driver who was in the country illegally.
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has since moved to tighten the rules and pressured several states, including New York and California, over how they issue the licenses. The administration has argued that states must not let foreign drivers keep licenses after their legal status ends.
Supporters of the crackdown say it protects highway safety, while critics argue it threatens the jobs of immigrant drivers who are in the country legally.
The trucking industry has long faced driver shortages, and immigrant drivers make up a significant share of the workforce.
What does the ruling mean for New York?
The decision bars the department from withholding the $73 million on these grounds. The $73 million is a small share of New York’s federal transportation funding, but the case carries broader stakes.
It also limits how far the federal government can go in using funding to push states on licensing rules that are not clearly written into regulation.
Courts generally require agencies to follow the text of their own rules when they impose penalties.
The ruling could influence similar disputes over commercial driver’s licenses in other states.
What happens next?
The department could ask the full appeals court to review the case or take it to the Supreme Court. It could also try to change the regulation to add an explicit expiration requirement. A new rule would need to go through the federal rulemaking process, which can take months.
For drivers who hold commercial driver’s licenses in New York, the ruling offers at least temporary relief. The broader debate over who should hold commercial driver’s licenses is far from over.

